Before I moved to Queens, I would travel from upstate New York to Long Island for marathon band practices and recording sessions with my band The Boys' Star Library. We worked hard throughout the day, often forgetting to consume anything save for cans of Milwaukee's Best Light and drags on heinous Parliament cigarettes between songs.
However, once we were played out we would venture to one of the thousands of strip malls that line the Island to a pizza shop that served up the most unique pie I've ever eaten - the roast beef pizza. Simply put it was a pizza topped with a thick pan gravy, thinly sliced roast beef and decadent dollops of creamy mashed potatoes. Ringing the register at over thirty dollars a pie, we would split the bill and use the hearty dose of carbs and protein to recover and fortify us for another day of making obscure indie rock music in a suburban basement.
The roast beef pie crept back into my mind after all these years after taking down a seasonal specialty pizza called "The Ballpark" at Dewey's, a midwest pizza chain based out of Ohio.
Served only in April, The Ballpark is a pizza topped with a spicy mustard, mozzarella cheese, sauerkraut, caramelized red onions and a spicy smoked sausage.
Paying homage to a ball park dog, The Ballpark reminds me little of the sad hot dogs that can be found at Busch Stadium here in St. Louis. Instead I think it has more in common with a Maxwell Street Polish Sausage, a specialty dog from Chicago.
The dough for this pie is standard for Dewey's - light and airy with what appears to be a light wash of oil on the bone. I've yet to run across another dough like Dewey's, which reminds me of a pub house pretzel.
In the place of tomato sauce we find a classic spicy yellow mustard that beyond reminding me of a healthy dose of Gulden's, was largely unforgettable.
Next up was a layer of mozzarella cheese to provide a kind of base for the dense toppings to come. I felt like the mozzarella provided little to the pizza and I could have done without it all together. Besides melding in places with the other toppings, it did little to enhance the pie and I was left wondering why it was there in the first place.
After the cheese is a bed of sauerkraut, covering the pizza from edge to edge and throwing off an aroma that dominated the onions and sausage. While any of the three toppings could play lead on a pizza, for me sauerkraut is the marque player in this dish. I especially liked how the chew of the Dewey's crust and the sauerkraut complemented each other - again the pretzel-like nature of the dough seemed right at home with the fermented cabbage.
On top of the sauerkraut came less than generous slices of sausage given the linage that this pizza is derived from. The Maxwell Street Polish Sausage is dense, meaty, flows over the bun and requires the eater to perform the "Philly Lean" so as to not get the dog all over their clothes. I so wanted the sausage to stand out in this pizza, alas it did not. While this is not to say it was bad, it just could have been so much better.
Lastly we have a sparse layer of caramelized red onions which were tasty but to few in number than to provide some color and residual sweetness every fifth bite or so. Again I was disappointed, anyone who has seen a vendor serving up Maxwell Streets will recall that their flat top almost always contains a monstrous pile of onions, towering over the sausages. Onions, you are missed on this pizza.
For me, I would suggest foregoing the cheese and making a larger investment in the sausage and onion. I think this pizza demands it. Missed opportunities aside, The Ballpark gets cut some slack because its unique and holds a limited engagement on the menu. It says welcome spring and gets me in the mood for nine dollar beers at the stadium.
Get yourself one before its gone till the 2011 season.